论文标题

数据质量,不匹配的期望和移动要求:以用户为中心的仪表板设计的挑战

Data Quality, Mismatched Expectations, and Moving Requirements: The Challenges of User-Centred Dashboard Design

论文作者

Alhamadi, Mohammed, Alghamdi, Omar, Clinch, Sarah, Vigo, Markel

论文摘要

交互式信息仪表板可以帮助专家和公众了解复杂数据集;但是,与这些仪表板进行互动通常会给用户带来挑战,例如理解和验证提出的信息。为了克服这些挑战,开发人员首先需要对用户观点有透彻的了解,包括用户在出现有问题的仪表板时采取的策略。我们采访了17个仪表板开发人员,以建立(i)他们对用户问题的理解,(ii)结果引入了适应,(iii)用户泰式仪表板是否可以迎合用户的个体差异。我们发现,用户的识字率通常与使用仪表板所需的素养不符,而仪表板开发人员则难以跟上不断变化的需求。我们还发现,开发人员能够为大多数用户的问题提出解决方案,但不是全部。令人鼓舞的是,我们的发现还强调,根据个人用户需求的量身定制仪表板不仅是可取的,而且是可行的。这些发现为未来的仪表板设计建议提供了建议,这些建议可以减轻确定的挑战,包括有关数据显示和视觉素养的建议。

Interactive information dashboards can help both specialists and the general public understand complex datasets; but interacting with these dashboards often presents users with challenges such as understanding and verifying the presented information. To overcome these challenges, developers first need to acquire a thorough understanding of user perspectives, including strategies that users take when presented with problematic dashboards. We interviewed seventeen dashboard developers to establish (i) their understanding of user problems, (ii) the adaptations introduced as a result, and (iii) whether user-tailored dashboards can cater for users' individual differences. We find that users' literacy does not typically align with that required to use dashboards, while dashboard developers struggle with keeping up with changing requirements. We also find that developers are able to propose solutions to most users' problems but not all. Encouragingly, our findings also highlight that tailoring dashboards to individual user needs is not only desirable, but also feasible. These findings inform future dashboard design recommendations that can mitigate the identified challenges including recommendations for data presentation and visual literacy.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源